A $340,000 house with 3% down needs about $10,200 before you pay a single closing cost. For a household sitting on $6,000 in savings, that gap decides whether the keys arrive this spring or three years from now. Which is why so many buyers search for mortgage lenders with forgivable down payment loans, and why so many of them get told the same thing by a loan officer: that program doesn’t exist.
It does exist. It just rarely comes from the lender’s own pocket.
What “Forgivable” Actually Means in a Mortgage File
A forgivable down payment loan is a second mortgage, usually at 0% interest, with no monthly payment. The balance disappears on a schedule written into the note. Most commonly, one-sixtieth of the loan is forgiven each month across five years. Some programs forgive the entire amount on a single date, often at year ten.
Attached to that schedule are conditions. You have to live in the home as your primary residence. You can’t rent it out. You usually can’t refinance the first mortgage without the second lien holder’s permission. Sell or move out at year two of a five-year clock, and the remaining balance comes due out of your sale proceeds, sometimes with a pro-rated penalty tacked on.
The money is real. The lien is real. The forgiveness is conditional.
Three products buyers regularly mix up
- Grants. No lien is recorded and nothing technically gets forgiven. You simply keep the money if you stay in the home for a set period, often five years.
- Forgivable seconds. A lien on title, 0% interest, balance wiped out in increments as long as you keep the terms.
- Deferred seconds. Also 0% interest, also no monthly payment, but the entire balance is owed when you sell, refinance, or pay off the first mortgage. Nothing is forgiven. A surprising share of programs advertised as forgivable are this instead.
On a $12,000 second mortgage, the gap between a deferred loan and a forgivable loan is the difference between walking away with that equity at resale and handing it back. Always ask which of the three you’re being quoted.
Who Actually Funds These Loans
Follow the money and you usually end up at a state housing finance agency, a city or county housing department, a nonprofit, or an employer. These entities have capital set aside from mortgage revenue bonds, HUD HOME funds, or their own budgets, and they need a licensed lender to originate, underwrite, and close the loan. That lender is the one whose name goes on your paperwork. It’s also frequently not the source of the assistance.
This split explains a lot of confusion at the kitchen table. A loan officer at a regional bank may offer a forgivable second because the state agency approved that bank to administer the program, not because the bank decided to be generous. Tracing where down payment assistance money actually originates is the fastest way to figure out which programs you’re genuinely eligible for and which ones just sound good on a flyer.
Grants work the same way, and they’re worth understanding separately because the paperwork is lighter and the repayment risk is lower. If you want lenders with grant money rather than forgivable seconds, the funding trail looks identical but the exit rules are friendlier.
Where Forgivable Programs Show Up in Practice
State housing finance agencies
Nearly every state runs at least one. Illinois Housing Development Authority’s Access Forgivable product is a genuine forgivable second aimed at first-time buyers under income limits. Massachusetts, Colorado, Texas, and Minnesota all run comparable structures, sometimes forgivable, sometimes deferred, and the two versions sit side by side in the same brochure. California’s CalHFA MyHome is a deferred second, not a forgivable one, which is exactly the kind of detail that gets lost in a marketing email.
City and county programs
Local programs tend to be smaller, more targeted, and more generous per dollar. A county might offer $15,000 forgivable over five years to buyers under 80% of area median income purchasing inside specific census tracts. These are the programs most people never find, because they don’t advertise and the application window can be three weeks long.
National lenders running agency programs
Large servicers participate in these constantly. Chase and Wells Fargo have both run homebuyer grant programs worth up to $10,000 in designated neighborhoods, structured so nothing is repaid if you keep the home as your primary residence for the required period. Chenoa Fund offers second-lien down payment products, with a forgivable version alongside its repayable one. Bank of America’s Community Affordable Loan Solution skips the down payment entirely, though it’s a 100% loan-to-value first mortgage rather than a forgivable second, which is a different animal.
None of these are universal. Eligibility is tied to income, geography, purchase price, and sometimes to which loan officer you happen to call.
The Fine Print That Decides Whether You Win
Stacking limits
Forgivable seconds don’t exist in isolation. FHA permits down payment assistance from government entities and approved nonprofits, and combined loan-to-value can run above 100% in some scenarios. Conventional programs cap the combined LTV more tightly. If you’re pairing assistance with a 3.5% FHA loan, understanding which lenders genuinely approve 3.5% down FHA loans matters, because a lender that won’t touch a stacked second kills the whole plan at the pre-approval stage.
Recapture and repayment triggers
Some bond-funded programs carry a federal recapture tax if you sell within nine years at a gain. Others claw back the full assistance if you refinance during the forgiveness period, which means the low rate you’re enjoying today can quietly become a trap if rates fall and you want to refinance in year three.
Closing costs don’t disappear
A forgivable second covers the down payment. It usually doesn’t cover the $7,000 to $11,000 in lender fees, title, appraisal, and prepaid escrows that come with the purchase. Finding lenders with genuinely low cash to close is a separate search from finding down payment help, and buyers who only solve half the problem still get stuck at the closing table.
How to Find a Lender That Administers One
Don’t start with a rate quote. Start with the program, then find a lender approved to originate it.
- Check your state housing finance agency’s approved lender list. Those lenders handle the program paperwork weekly and won’t fumble it.
- Call two or three HUD-approved housing counseling agencies and ask which forgivable programs are currently funded in your county. Counselors see the list refresh and know which ones have money left.
- Ask your city’s housing department directly. Many publish assistance programs on a page nobody links to.
- Ask HR whether your employer participates in an employer-assisted housing program. These are common with hospitals, universities, and large manufacturers, and they’re often forgivable over five years.
- When you call a lender, ask a specific question: “Do you originate forgivable second mortgages through our state housing agency?” A vague yes usually means no.
What the Cheap Down Payment Really Costs
Assistance programs frequently come with a slightly higher first-mortgage rate, a lender fee, or both. A 0.375% rate bump on a $320,000 loan runs about $70 a month, or roughly $25,000 over thirty years. That doesn’t make the program a bad deal, especially if the alternative is waiting two more years while rents climb. It does mean you should compare the total package rather than the down payment figure alone.
Run the numbers on a straight low-down-payment loan too. Comparing what 3% down loans actually cost against a forgivable second plus a rate bump often reveals the two paths land within a few thousand dollars of each other over the life of the loan, and the simpler one may win.
Five Questions to Ask Before You Sign
These separate a real forgivable loan from a marketing line, and the answers should be in writing before you pay for an appraisal.
- Is the forgiveness scheduled, or is the whole balance due at payoff? If it’s the latter, you have a deferred loan.
- What exactly triggers repayment? Sale, refinance, renting the property, a change in income, or a lien position change all count in some programs.
- Is the forgiveness pro-rated or all-or-nothing? Pro-rated means leaving in year two costs you 60% of the balance, not 100%.
- Does this program carry a recapture tax or shared appreciation clause? Both reduce what you keep at resale.
- Who services the second, and who do I call when I want a payoff statement? Getting this wrong at refinance time can delay a closing by weeks.
Get those five answers and you’ll know within an hour whether the offer in front of you is worth pursuing or whether you should keep calling counseling agencies until a better one turns up.
