Somewhere on the loan estimate you got last week there’s a line marked “discount points,” and the number next to it probably made you flinch. That number is a permanent rate buydown: you hand the lender a lump sum at closing and your interest rate drops for as long as you keep the loan. No annual reset. No fine print that quietly expires in year three.
Most borrowers skim right past it, because $4,000 up front looks enormous next to a monthly payment that only moves by $60 or $70. Over 30 years, though, that $60 is worth tens of thousands. Whether a buydown makes sense comes down to two questions: how long you’ll actually keep this loan, and how well you shopped the pricing.
What “permanent” really means in a rate buydown
A permanent buydown is the plain-vanilla version of paying points. One point equals 1% of the loan amount. On a $400,000 mortgage, one point is $4,000. You pay it at closing, the lender lowers your note rate, and the lower rate stays put for the full term.
Permanent versus temporary: a distinction that trips people up
The 2-1 buydown you’ve seen in builder ads is a different animal. That’s a temporary buydown funded through an escrow account. Your rate is 2% below the note rate in year one, 1% below in year two, then snaps to full price in year three. The seller or builder usually pays for it. A permanent buydown never rises, but you (or a seller credit) fund it yourself.
There’s also the “lender-paid” label floating around. Read the fine print. It usually means the lender covers the points while charging you a higher base rate to compensate. You’re still paying, just in installments instead of a check.
Mortgage lenders offering permanent rate buydowns
Here’s the part that surprises people: permanent buydowns aren’t a specialty product. Almost any lender that sells loans to Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac will let you buy points, and FHA, VA, and USDA loans allow them too. The real difference between lenders isn’t whether they offer it. It’s how much rate they give you per point.
- Large retail banks. Chase, Wells Fargo, and similar institutions all offer discount points. Pricing tends to be middling, but existing customers sometimes get relationship discounts worth asking about.
- Non-bank and online lenders. Rocket, LoanDepot, and the online-only crowd compete hard on posted rates and generally publish a points menu.
- Credit unions. Often competitive, occasionally exceptional. Membership rules apply, so check eligibility before you fall in love with a rate.
- Mortgage brokers with wholesale access. Brokers can price the same loan across dozens of investors in an afternoon, which is how you find the lender whose point-to-rate grid is genuinely sharp rather than just advertised as sharp.
- Builder captive lenders. These produce the splashiest headlines, like a 5.99% rate when the market sits at 6.75%. The catch is that the incentive is usually tied to using their lender and their title company, and the cost can be baked into the home price.
- Community banks and portfolio lenders. Institutions that hold loans on their own books have freedom to structure things creatively. Worth a call if your situation is unusual.
Running the numbers on a real buydown
Take a $400,000 loan at 6.75%. Principal and interest runs about $2,594 a month. Now say you pay one point, $4,000, to drop the rate to 6.50%. The payment falls to roughly $2,529. That’s $65 a month, or $780 a year, for a one-time cost of $4,000.
Break-even is the only number that matters
Divide the cost by the monthly savings: $4,000 ÷ $65 comes out to about 61 months, a hair over five years. If you sell or refinance in year four, you’ve handed the lender $4,000 and collected roughly $3,100 of benefit. You lost money. Stay eight years and you’re ahead by more than $2,200, with a smaller balance still compounding in your favor.
Two points usually buys roughly twice the rate reduction, so the break-even stays in the same neighborhood: about $8,000 for a 0.5% cut and $130 a month, still landing near five years. The math is more stubborn than it looks, which is why the hidden truth about home buying in today’s market is worth reading before you commit to a decade-long holding period you haven’t actually stress-tested.
Shop the point-to-rate grid, not the headline rate
The most common expensive mistake is comparing lenders on the zero-point rate alone. Ask every lender for the same scenario quoted at zero, one, and two points on the same day, ideally within a couple of hours, since rates move intraday.
You’ll find real dispersion. One lender might charge 1.25 points for a 0.375% reduction while another charges a full point for 0.25%. Same loan, same borrower, materially different value. The gap often comes from the wholesale versus retail channel, which is exactly where a broker earns their keep.
Ignore APR for this comparison. It bundles fees and points into one number and muddies the specific question you’re asking: what does each dollar of buydown actually purchase?
Where the cash for points usually comes from
Most buyers don’t write a separate check. They use seller concessions, which are capped by loan type. Conventional loans allow 3% with less than 10% down, 6% at 10% to 25% down, and 9% above that. FHA caps at 6%, and VA at 4% for certain closing costs. Builder incentives work similarly, though you should always ask what the price would be without the incentive attached.
Raiding your down payment to buy points is usually a bad trade. Dropping below 20% triggers mortgage insurance, and the PMI bill can easily exceed the payment savings from the buydown. Keep three to six months of reserves untouched, too. A paid-down rate doesn’t help when the water heater dies in February.
Who the buydown helps and who it hurts
Permanent buydowns reward stability. If you’re settling into a house you plan to keep for a decade, have cash beyond your reserves, and would rather lock in a known payment than chase a refinance later, buying points is a reasonable, low-drama move. Retirees on fixed incomes often like them for the same reason.
They punish mobility. Job moves, growing families, and divorce all shorten holding periods more often than people expect. And if rates fall two years from now, you’ll refinance and write off the unamortized points entirely. Think hard before paying for a buydown if you’re already planning to refinance the moment the market cooperates. Run the arithmetic on your own numbers rather than trusting a rule of thumb; the math nobody shows you at the open house tends to change the answer.
Red flags in a buydown quote
Watch for a few patterns that separate a fair quote from a padded one.
- Vague point costs. A lender who won’t state a precise dollar figure per rate tier is hiding something.
- Points buried in a “discount” that’s really origination fee. Ask for the line-item breakdown on the loan estimate, not a summary.
- Pressure to buy points without a break-even calculation. Any honest loan officer will run the months-to-recoup figure with you and tell you when it doesn’t work.
- Quotes that ignore seller credits. If the seller will fund concessions, those dollars buy points more efficiently than cash from your savings account.
- No lender credit option presented. Negative points exist. You can take a slightly higher rate and have the lender cover closing costs, which is the right call for some buyers.
Get three quotes, same day, same loan amount, and make each lender show you the cost per eighth of a percent. The lender offering permanent rate buydowns at the best value is rarely the one with the flashiest advertisement. It’s the one whose grid holds up when you divide the cost by the monthly savings and count the months out loud.
