Two buyers make an offer on the same $400,000 house. One uses a VA loan, the other a conventional loan. Their rates might be within an eighth of a point. Their monthly payments could still differ by hundreds of dollars, and one buyer may need $20,000 more at closing. The VA loan vs conventional loan decision is not a coin flip. Each loan follows different rules on cash, insurance, credit, and property.
Down Payment: 0% vs 3% to 20%
VA loans let eligible borrowers buy with no down payment. Conventional loans typically require 3% down for first-time buyers, 5% for standard programs, or 20% to avoid PMI. On a $400,000 home, the cash difference looks like this:
- VA loan: $0 down
- Conventional, 3% down: $12,000
- Conventional, 5% down: $20,000
- Conventional, 20% down: $80,000
VA loans have county limits on zero-down borrowing. The 2024 baseline is $766,550, with high-cost areas higher. VA loan limits explained covers how the zero-down ceiling works.
Mortgage Insurance: PMI vs the VA Funding Fee
Conventional loans with less than 20% down usually carry PMI. On a $400,000 loan with 5% down and a 700 score, PMI often runs $170 to $250 per month. It stops at 20% equity. VA loans have no monthly PMI. Instead, there is a one-time funding fee: 2.15% for first use with 0% down, 3.3% for repeat use. On $400,000, that is $8,600 or $13,200, and it can be financed.
Break-even math is simple. At $200 per month PMI, $8,600 takes 43 months. Stay longer than about three and a half years and the VA loan often costs less. Sell sooner and conventional can win. That timing is the heart of any conventional loan vs VA loan comparison.
Credit Scores and Debt-to-Income: Different Bars
The VA does not set a minimum credit score; lenders do. Most VA lenders want 580 to 620. Some go to 500 with 10% down. Conventional loans usually require 620, and 3% down programs often need 620 or higher. VA allows DTI up to 41% with compensating factors, sometimes 50%. Conventional caps around 45% to 50% with less flexibility. VA also uses residual income, a leftover-cash rule. Conventional wins on speed: 21 to 30 days versus 30 to 45 for VA, which needs a VA appraisal and Certificate of Eligibility.
Property Rules: VA Is Pickier About the House
VA appraisals enforce Minimum Property Requirements. Peeling paint, exposed wiring, a bad roof, or a broken furnace can stall the loan until fixed. Conventional appraisals mostly check value. Condos add another hurdle: the project must be VA-approved. VA loan for condos explains why that approval has nothing to do with your finances.
Loan Limits and Jumbo Territory
Conventional conforming and VA loans share the same 2024 baseline limit: $766,550, or up to $1,149,825 in high-cost counties. With full VA entitlement, you can borrow above the limit with a down payment. That is a VA jumbo loan, and it adds a second-tier review. VA jumbo loan requirements cover the extra down payment and review. Conventional jumbo loans usually want 10% to 20% down and a 700-plus score.
Assumability: The VA Loan’s Quiet Advantage
VA loans are assumable. A qualified buyer can take over your loan and its rate when you sell. Conventional loans usually have a due-on-sale clause. If you have a 3% VA loan and rates are 7%, assumability can make your home easier to sell. The buyer must be VA-eligible or approved, and you may lose part of your entitlement until the loan is paid off.
Seller Concessions and Closing Costs
VA sellers can pay up to 4% in concessions. Conventional allows 3% if your down payment is under 10%, 6% for 10% to 25%, and 9% for 25% or more. VA also caps some closing costs, including a 1% origination fee limit with exceptions. Compare Loan Estimates, not just rates.
When the VA Loan Wins, and When Conventional Wins
Neither loan is universally better. The right pick depends on your cash, credit, timeline, and the property itself.
- VA wins if: you have little cash, want no monthly PMI, have a 580 to 620 score, plan to stay four-plus years, or value assumability.
- Conventional wins if: you have 20% down, need a fast close, are buying a condo that is not VA-approved, want an investment property, or your loan exceeds the VA limit and you want to avoid a down payment.
VA loans are for primary residences only. Conventional loans can cover second homes and rentals, with different terms.
How to Compare Both Without Getting Buried in APR
The four numbers that matter
Ask two lenders for Loan Estimates on the same house, one VA and one conventional. Compare cash to close, total monthly payment including PMI or the financed funding fee, loan balance after five years, and total cost over seven years. A VA loan at 6.5% with no PMI can beat a conventional loan at 6.25% with $200 per month PMI.
If you are a reservist or active duty and unsure about eligibility, VA loans for reservists covers what counts and what does not. Do not waive your financing contingency on an assumption.
